Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Inquest: Teoh 80% homicide!!!

Now the balance of probability of death is shifted toward 80% homicide!!! This is very serious as it should be re-classified as homicide until evidence disproves it. As for a homicide case, even though the body remains found 6 months later could be examined for cracks and signs of fracture skull and broken bones in order to determine the cause of death. I admire her courage to speak in truth based on her expert knowledge from years of experience in the field of her work. For true justice to Teoh Beng Hock, an autopsy by Dr. Pornthip would be necessary unless her statement under oath could be accepted as evidence without further questions.

21.10.2009

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

21-10-2009 SHAH ALAM: There is an 80% probability that the death of political aide Teoh Beng Hock was a homicide, said renowned Thai forensic pathologist Dr Pornthip Rojanasunand.

Testifying in the inquest into Teoh's death Wednesday, she said there was only a 20% chance that Teoh had committed suicide.

Thai pathologist Dr. Pornthip Rojanasunand

She added that marks on Teoh's neck region looked like he had been strangled manually.

"The contusion of the skin on the right side of the neck looks round, indicating it might have been caused by fingers," she added.

Counsel representing the government Tan Hock Chuan then suggested that she did not have the locus standi to arrive at her opinion.

"Since you did not conduct the post mortem or inspect the body or go to the scene of the incident and not furnished with the report and photos, is it not appropriate to form an opinion on mathematical terms that suicide is 20% and homicide 80%?" he asked.

Dr Pornthip replied she did not take sides and her work involved taking care of the rights of the dead, adding that she only based her opinions on the evidence provided.

This prompted Tan to rephrase the question by suggesting that the limitations she faced was insufficient to help Dr Pornthip to arrive at the conclusion that it was 80% homicide and 20% suicide.

"It is my field, my work and I believe in that. It is more scientific," said Dr Pornthip, adding that she did not agree with some opinions of Universiti Malaya Medical Centre's Dr Prashant Samberkar on why Teoh's death could have been a suicide.

However, she added she did not want to criticise the opinions of other forensic pathologists.

She said her opinion was based on her years of experience and not aimed at contradicting the police or other medical professionals.

Dr Pornthip, who is the director-general of Thailand's Ministry of Justices Central Institute of Forensic Science, had been invited to give her expert opinion by the Selangor state government.

She is well-known for her prowess in solving complicated homicide cases and is a celebrity of sorts in her homeland.

She is the author of Investigation of Corpses which sold 100,000 copies in Thailand, and also led a group of international forensic scientists in 2004 to identify the remains of the Asian tsunami victims.

Her life and work was narrated in a National Geographic documentary entitled Crime Scene Bangkok in 2004.

Dr Pornthip told coroner Azmil Muntapha Abas that she is willing to conduct a second post mortem on Teoh if his remains are exhumed.

She said she would be able to come up with a more concise and detailed analysis if she could examine Teoh's remains.

To a question by Gobind Singh Deo who is holding a watching brief for Teoh's family, Dr Pornthip said she would still be able to conduct the post-mortem in spite of the deceased being buried almost four months ago.

When asked if the second post mortem on Teoh's body would put her to a disadvantage, Dr Pornthip said there would not be any disadvantages but only limitations due to the decomposition which could destroy everything if a second post-mortem was prolonged.

Questioned by Malik Imtiaz Sarwar, the counsel holding a watching brief for the Selangor government, Dr Pornthip said several injuries sustained by Teoh appeared to be inconsistent with a fall from a high place, and appeared to be pre-fall injuries instead.

(Dr Pornthip had been provided with pictures of Teoh's injuries and post-mortem reports by Dr Khairul Aznam Ibrahim from the Tengku Ampuan Rahimah Hospital and by Universiti Malaya Medical Centre's Dr Prashant Samberkar).

Malik Imtiaz: Can you explain why not all the injuries were consistent with a fall from a height?

Dr Pornthip: The first is the anal injury; from the picture there's a penetrative injury at the anal region. I have never seen this type of injury in cases of fall from height.

She added that if the injury had indeed been caused by a bone protrusion, it would have come from the inside of Teoh's anus as opposed to being a penetrative injury.

Dr Pornthip also said the abrasions found on Teoh's upper right thigh also appeared like he had been beaten with a piece of wood.

There is more than one line and the direction of the force on the thigh is different from the direction of the penetrative injury to the anal region, she said.

According to Dr Pornthip, there was a need to open the skin in the area where the haemorrhage was found to determine if torture had been involved. (Both the pathologists who had conducted the post-mortem on Teoh had failed to do so.)

She added this was necessary to determine whether the haemorrhage was compatible with a fall from a height and single impact from the ground.

Dr Pornthip also said Teoh's skull fracture was not typical of a transferred injury due to a fall but was more compatible with a blunt force being directly inflicted to the head.

She said the transferred injury to the skull due to impact of the fall would typically cause a ring fracture at the base of the skull around the spinal column and not a cervical spine fracture such as that suffered by Teoh.

Dr Pornthip said Teoh, 30, was probably alive when he hit the ground but may have been unconscious before the fall.

She added this was in view of the fact that there was no reaction or defensive wounds on his ankles and wrists which would have occurred if he had been conscious.

Dr Pornthip added that these wounds would occur when a conscious person tries to break his fall which was a natural reaction when one is falling from height.

There's a possibility that he was unconscious from the manual strangulation or pain from the anal region, she said.

Teoh, the political secretary to Selangor executive councillor Ean Yong Hian Wah, had been summoned to the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) office at the 14th floor of Plaza Masalam to be questioned over the irregular disbursement of state funds on July 15.

He was found dead on the fifth floor service corridor of the building the following day.

Meanwhile, the Selangor government called on the authorities to study the evidence of Dr Pornthip that Teoh's death was a probable homicide and that he could have been strangled before falling from the 14th floor of Plaza Masalam.

"Her evidence has indeed proven that the state's fear on the safety of government officials during interrogation by MACC is not totally unfounded," said Selangor Mentri Besar Tan Sri Khalid Samad in a statement Wednesday.

Given her experience, he said that Dr Pornthip's evidence could not be taken lightly.

He reiterated his government's call for a Royal Commission of Inquiry into Teoh's death instead of just looking into the interrogation methods used on him by the MACC.

The inquest has been adjourned to Nov 9.

http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/10/21/nation/20091021102728&sec=nation

Friday, September 11, 2009

Comments on MACC officers lodge police report to deny torturing suspect

SHAH ALAM, Sept 9, 2009 – Five Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) officers, including Mohd Ashraf Mohd Yunus, the witness in the inquest into the death of political aide Teoh Beng Hock, lodged a report at the Shah Alam police headquarters here today.

Selangor MACC director Jaafar Mahad said the officers lodged the report at 4.30pm refuting the allegation that MACC officers' had used force during interrogation.

"We are refuting the allegation that we tortured the suspect. The statement made during the inquest proceedings was ill intent and meant to mar the reputation of the MACC," he told reporters after accompanying the officers to the police headquarters to lodge the report.

In the inquest proceedings earlier today, T. Sivanesan, a witness called by the lawyer representing Teoh's family, Gobind Singh Deo, claimed that he was tortured by MACC officers during interrogation.

Teoh, 30, was found dead on the fifth floor of Plaza Masalam on July 16, after giving statement to the Selangor MACC, located on the 14th floor of the same building. – Bernama

http://www.themalaysianinsider.net.my/index.php/malaysia/37306-five-macc-officers-lodge-police-report-to-deny-torturing-suspect


COMMENTS

The workforce of MACC does not comprise of only 5 MACC Officers. So the 5 MACC Officers are the good ones. Where are the other MACC Officers? Does it mean those who did not appear at the Police Station did torture the witnesses and compel them to disclose as much information as possible.

Secondly, why the Police did not investigate  Sivanesan's police report last year? Now of course the injuries on the body of Sivanesan had healed. But the medical report, photos of the injuries and the boldness to testify at the inquest speaks volumes. MACC has the losing battle to fight on.

Let's see what the common people think about MACC!


written by Leong Yook Kong, September 09, 2009
Why the 5 MACC offiers waited for such a long time to lodge police report to refute or counter the allegation made by the mysterious witness, Mr. T. Sivanesan? Correct me if I am wrong. I think the mysterious witness lodged the police report some where in September 2008. This is called "a tooth for a tooth". 

What Siva wanted to do is to seek justice for Teoh Beng Hock? That is the real reason, he volunteers to testify today. Siva, you are our hero. The question that strikes my mind is "Why the police did not investigate the report lodged by Siva ages ago"? If this had been done when the report was lodged, the story would had been totally different today. So, who will take the blame now? They asked for it.


written by focussed08, September 09, 2009

Hey, why only 5 officers lodge police reports. The whole department should lodge police reports to ensure a more thorough investigation could be initiated. 

The whole department should lodge police departments because those who had lodged police reports most probably do not have any recorded history of actually being involved in use of force against witnesses or suspects (unless identified by the witness) but others in the department might have a history of violence towards witnesses or suspects and dare not lodge any police reports. 

There is always something called peers pressure and once a "leader" starts using violence, the rest of his/her subordinates will be more inclined to follow suit in order to remain as an acceptable member of the group. Once violence is initiated, a feeding frenzy of violence will ensue as herd mentality takes over the group.


written by HJ Angus, September 10, 2009
Surely this is not the correct procedure. 
Otherwise anyone can lodge a police report to counteract any reported crime and there will be no use of the courts. 
If a police report has been made, the police should check out the facts of that report and if a false report had been lodged, action can be taken against the person.


Monday, September 7, 2009

Comments on Teoh family outraged at MACC chief's suicide theory

KUALA LUMPUR, Sept 7, 2009 – As the inquest into the death of a Selangor government political aide drags on with no clear end in sight, his grieving family’s frustration is fast turning into fury.

This is especially over the latest reported remarks made by the chief commissioner of the national anti-graft body, which many believe to have had a hand in pushing him over the edge.

The family of the late Teoh Beng Hock denounced the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission’s (MACC) Datuk Seri Ahmad Said Hamdan for publicly insinuating that the 30-year-old political secretary had committed suicide because he “could not withstand the pressure”.


Teoh’s younger sister, Lee Lan noted that Ahmad Said had told Chinese-language daily, Sin Chew Daily, earlier this month that he had been informed of 10 cases of people jumping from buildings after being investigated by Hong Kong’s Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) since its set-up.

The MACC, formed in January this year, was modelled after the ICAC.

“He also said that if people investigated could not withstand the pressure and jumped from the building, there was nothing that they (MACC) could do,” Lee Lan told The Malaysian Insider, repeating her statement to reporters last Saturday after saying prayers for her brother at the Seck Kia Eenh Temple in Malacca.

“If the MACC continues to make irresponsible remarks which cannot be substantiated with proof, we are prepared to go and see the Prime Minister again to urge him to immediately set up a comprehensive Royal Commission of Inquiry to investigate into Beng Hock’s cause of death,” she added, speaking for the rest of her family.

The family scored a meeting with Datuk Seri Najib Razak in his Putrajaya office on July 28.

“No stone will be left unturned in finding out the real cause of death and, if there is any foul play, action will definitely be taken,” the PM promised them then.

Lee Lan, who was the closest of three other siblings to Teoh, challenged Ahmad Said to answer three questions:

1. Who saw Beng Hock jump from [the] MACC building?

2. Beng Hock was classified as a witness in the investigation, what pressure would he have faced?

3. Will MACC’s interrogation method bring about pressure on the witness or suspect to cause them to jump to death?

Teoh was found dead outside the MACC’s Selangor office in Plaza Masalam, Shah Alam on July 16, the same day he was to register his marriage to his pregnant sweetheart.

He had been interrogated overnight by MACC investigators probing claims that his boss, first-term Selangor DAP state lawmaker and executive councillor Ean Yong Hian Wah, had unlawfully dipped his fingers into state funds.

The inquest will resume tomorrow after a one week break.

Source: http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/index.php/malaysia/37113-teoh-family-outraged-at-macc-chiefs-suicide-theory


Tsu Koon tells MACC chief to be more sensitive

Ahmad Said was quoted to have said that in the history of the Independent Commission for Anti-Corruption (ICAC) of Hong Kong, there were a total of 11 suicides of suspects and that there was nothing that the ICAC could do about it.

“Although this may have been a statement of fact with respect to the ICAC, an open comment by the MACC Chief at this juncture when the inquest is on-going could be construed and perceived as suggesting that suicide might have been the cause of Teoh’s death, while the inquest has not come to any conclusive judgment,” said Koh

Ahmad Said was quoted to have said that in the history of the Independent Commission for Anti-Corruption (ICAC) of Hong Kong, there were a total of 11 suicides of suspects and that there was nothing that the ICAC could do about it.

“Although this may have been a statement of fact with respect to the ICAC, an open comment by the MACC Chief at this juncture when the inquest is on-going could be construed and perceived as suggesting that suicide might have been the cause of Teoh’s death, while the inquest has not come to any conclusive judgment,” said Tan Sri Koh Tsu Koon.


COMMENTS:


I would like MACC to elaborate on these few questions and see if the number of death under ICAC is conclusive for the death of Teoh Beng Hock!


How was the method of interrogation of HK's ICAC similar to MACC? MACC Officer Mohd Ashraf Mohd Yunus had testified there was only an interview and not interrogation. So what pressure was Ahmad Said talking about?


Knowing that there were 10 suicide cases of death under ICAC because of "pressure" from investigation, why MACC did not take precaution to safeguard the safety of Teoh Beng Hock until he left the premises???


Out of the 10 cases of death under HK's ICAC, how many cases were death at the building of ICAC and it covers the span of how many years to produce the statistic of 10 suicide cases?


How old is MACC to produce 1 death in custody of MACC?


Why there were 1 known DNA of "Male 1" on the belt of Teoh Beng Hock which has not yet been identified?


I highly suspect the DNA sampling of MACC Officers could be "switched" or "replaced" with other unknown people during the transit to the chemist lab. I strongly suggest to call for international DNA experts to extract the DNA sample from all the MACC Officers one more time in the presence of the lawyers for both parties of Teoh's family and MACC. The mystery letter still contains sufficient evidence to investigate further by independent Commission of Inquiry.